Mustang Vs Mustang: here’s why Pilots Preferred the P-51B/C “Razorback” and the Brass Preferred the P-51D “Bubbletop”

Mustang Vs Mustang: here’s why Pilots Preferred the P-51B/C “Razorback” while the Brass Preferred the P-51D “Bubbletop”

By Dario Leone
Aug 10 2023
Share this article

Between the P-51B/C ”Razorback” or the long-ranged P-51D, the P-51B Razorback was faster and flew straighter/smoother with the smooth-back fuselage and still got 1,350 miles of range.

In 1940 the British approached North American Aviation to license-build Curtiss P-40 fighters for the Royal Air Force. North American offered to design a better fighter, which flew as the NA-73X in October 1940. Production of the aircraft — named Mustang I by the British — began the following year.

In March 1942 the USAAF accepted the first production P-51A fighters. Although excellent at lower levels, the P-51A’s Allison engines severely limited performance at high altitude.

In the fall of 1942, Mustangs in the US and Great Britain were experimentally fitted with British Merlin engines. One in the US flew a remarkable 441 mph at 29,800 feet — about 100 mph faster than the P-51A at that altitude. Mass production of the Merlin-powered P-51B and P-51C soon followed (nearly identical, North American produced the “B” in Inglewood, Calif., and the “C” in Dallas, Texas).

In December 1943 the first P-51B/C Mustangs entered combat in Europe with the 354th Fighter Group “Pioneers.” By the time of the first US heavy bomber strike against Berlin in March 1944, the USAAF fielded about 175 P-51B/C Mustangs.

The P-51D incorporated several improvements, and it became the most numerous variant with nearly 8,000 being built. The most obvious change was a new “bubble-top” canopy that greatly improved the pilot’s vision. The P-51D also received the new K-14 gunsight, an increase from four to six .50-cal machine guns, and a simplified ammunition feed system that considerably reduced gun jams.

Here’s the real secret behind P-51B/C/D Mustang’s range

The P-51D arrived in quantity in Europe in the spring of 1944, becoming the USAAF’s primary long range escort fighter.

Something that almost nobody knows is that the pilots preferred the P-51B “razorback” and the Brass preferred the longer 1,650-mile ranged P-51D “Bubbletop.”

Pete Feigal, Former Pro Military Artist for 25 Years (CLICK HERE to visit his site and check out his awesome artworks), explains on Quora;

Between the P-51B/C ”Razorback” or the long-ranged P-51D, the P-51B Razorback was faster and flew straighter/smoother with the smooth-back fuselage and still got 1,350 miles of range. The Malcom “goldfish bowl” cockpit canopy also gave great visibility to the rear.

‘Both the “bubble-top” P-51 Mustangs and P-47 Thunderbolts had a slight instability issue when compared to the “razorback” variants and most had a stabilizer added to iron this out in later models.

‘Check out the smooth rear back/tail on this P-51B behind the substandard “greenhouse” canopy:

Red Tail P-51C print
This print is available in multiple sizes from AircraftProfilePrints.com – CLICK HERE TO GET  YOURS. P-51C-10 Flown by Tuskagee Airmen Col. Charles E. McGee, 302nd FS, 332nd FG, Italy

‘Now check out the dorsal fin for stability on the back/tail of this P-51D:

P-51D Mustang print
This print is available in multiple sizes from AircraftProfilePrints.com – CLICK HERE TO GET  YOURS. P-51D Mustang “Dorrie R” – 44-63422 / 134, 15th FG, 78th FS “Bushmasters” – 1945

‘In my years as a WWII aviation artist I heard something interesting, though: that many P-51 pilots greatly preferred the P-51B with the Malcolm Hood canopy. It was lighter, faster, and had crisper handling than the “bubble-top” P-51D and had a better all-round visibility. Its primary weakness was in its armament—only four Browning M2 .50’s, which often jammed, esp. under tight turning.

‘Some later mods to the P-51D to improve the ammunition feed racks were later retrofitted into P-51B/Cs, which made their .50s less prone to jamming. With modified guns and a Malcolm hood, the P-51B/C was arguably a better fighter than the P-51D, with better visibility, lower weight, a bit faster and without the structural problems which afflicted the D. Emergency bail-outs were also easier.’

Chris Chant explains in his book Allied Fighters 1939-45: ‘To many pilots, the P-51B was the finest variant of the P-51 Mustang. When fitted with the British “Malcolm hood”, it was lighter and faster, and handled more crisply than the bubble-canopied P-51Ds.’

Feigal continues;

‘These early canopies were made of numerous pieces of plain ol’ flat glass held in position by a frame and muntins (strip of metal separating and holding the glass panes).

The story of James Howard, the P-51 Mustang pilot who fought alone, for 30 minutes against Luftwaffe fighters to protect B-17 bombers egressing from skies over Germany
356th Fighter Squadron- North American P-51B-5 Mustang 43-6315 Ding Hao, flown by then Major James H. Howard (in cockpit) when he earned the Medal of Honor.

‘The muntins reduced visibility, which was especially awkward for combat aircraft. And glass canopies were significantly heavier than acrylic canopies, like the bubble canopies used on the Spitfire, which gave better all-round visibility and significantly reduced weight.

[Much of the original use of Plexiglass was for submarine periscopes and aircraft canopies, gun turrets and windscreens, esp. for the safety factor as pilots injured by glass shards in accidents/combat, esp. ad much more serious wounds, but with shards of Plexiglass, wounds and eyes healed much better/faster as Plexiglass had better compatibility between human tissue than glass and was also significantly duller than the razor-like shards of glass. Untold thousands of wounded pilots continued to see even with serious eye wounds when they would likely faced blindness from glass shards. Plus, the Plexiglass was also being used for pilot’s goggles. British manufacture and chemical engineering firm, R Malcolm & Co, found they could blow the heated substance almost exactly like fancy Italian glass blowers could blow heated glass, forming incredible new shapes including aircraft windscreens with “fish bowl” properties, giving the pilots more headroom and far better visibility, esp. to the rear, not to mention less serious eye wounds if shattered.]

‘Some of the Allied aircraft like the P-51B/C’s were still “razorbacks” even with the Malcolm hoods, but were further developed into the familiar “bubble tops” of the P-51Ds and P-47Ds. there was a minor speed penalty for the Malcolm hood ”bubble top” designs, but not much: for example, the P-51B/C w/”glasshouse” canopy made 441 mph, the P-51D, with the bubble canopy, made 437 mph, but far worth it for the increased visibility esp. to the rear.

The P-47 began the destruction of the Luftwaffe, the P-51D would complete the job. But without the P-51B air war might well have been lost..
P-51B with Malcom hood

‘The Malcom hood was originally developed for the Spitfire by the British company R Malcolm & Co which gave its name. Instead of taking a straight line between the canopy frames, the hood was bulged outward. This gave the pilot a better view to the rear.

‘When the Mustang III was delivered to England, the RAF did a major modification where the original framed hinged hood was replaced by a bulged Perspex frameless canopy that slid to the rear on rails.

‘This canopy gave the pilot much more room and the huge goldfish bowl afforded a good view almost straight down or directly to the rear. It was manufactured and fitted by the British corporation R Malcolm & Co, and became familiar as the Malcolm Hood. The hood was fitted to most RAF Mustang IIIs, and many USAAF Eighth and Ninth Air Force P-51B/C fighters received the modification as well.’

Feigal concludes

‘The Brass preferred the longer, 1,650-mile ranged “Bubble top” P-51D that could take the bombers to Berlin and back. It had a fuel capacity of 485 gallons, 85 more than the P-51B but that additional 85 gallons gave it 300 more miles of range, the difference in Berlin and back or not. It became the main produced P-51 and earned the love of her pilots.’

Mustang Vs Mustang: here’s why Pilots Preferred the P-51B/C “Razorback” and the Brass Preferred the P-51D “Bubbletop”
Two contrasting Mustangs variants painted in the blue nose markings of the 352nd Fighter Group famously based at Bodney during WW2. Nearest is a rare P-51C while behind is a P-51D. 

Photo credit: Alan Wilson via Wikipedia and U.S. Air Force

P-51B model
This model is available AirModels – CLICK HERE TO GET YOURS.

Share this article

Dario Leone

Dario Leone

Dario Leone is an aviation, defense and military writer. He is the Founder and Editor of “The Aviation Geek Club” one of the world’s most read military aviation blogs. His writing has appeared in The National Interest and other news media. He has reported from Europe and flown Super Puma and Cougar helicopters with the Swiss Air Force.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this article


Share this article
Share this article

Always up to date! News and offers delivered directly to you!

Get the best aviation news, stories and features from The Aviation Geek Club in our newsletter, delivered straight to your inbox.

Error: Contact form not found.


Share this article
Back to top
My Agile Privacy
This website uses technical and profiling cookies. Clicking on "Accept" authorises all profiling cookies. Clicking on "Refuse" or the X will refuse all profiling cookies. By clicking on "Customise" you can select which profiling cookies to activate. In addition, this site installs Google Analytics in version 4 (GA4) with anonymous data transmission via proxy. By giving your consent, the data will be sent anonymously, thus protecting your privacy. We and our selected ad partners can store and/or access information on your device, such as cookies, unique identifiers, browsing data. You can always choose the specific purposes related to profiling by accessing the advertising preferences panel, and you can always withdraw your consent at any time by clicking on "Manage consent" at the bottom of the page.

List of some possible advertising permissions:

You can consult: our list of advertising partners, the Cookie Policy and the Privacy Policy.
Warning: some page functionalities could not work due to your privacy choices