Losses and Aviation Safety

If Chesley Sullenberger’s Airbus A320 had ejection seats passengers would have died. Here are 7 reasons why it’s impossible to install ejection seats in commercial aircraft.

An ejection seat is an emergency, last ditch, all-else has failed alternative to death.

In aircraft, an ejection seat is a system designed to rescue the pilot or other crew of an aircraft in an emergency. In most designs, the aircraft canopy comes off and the seat is propelled out of the aircraft by an explosive charge or rocket motor, carrying the pilot with it. Once clear of the aircraft, the ejection seat deploys a parachute. In two seat aircraft, the seats are ejected at different angles to avoid a collision.

Before ejection seats, pilots would have to remove the aircraft canopy manually to climb and jump out.

Ejection seats can save lives. However, they are not used in commercial passenger aircraft. Why?

‘OK… there’s a few things that you aren’t aware of when it comes to ejection seats,’ says Jeff Chatterton, Communications Consultant to 7 Aviation Companies, on Quora.

a) Most pilots, IF they ever eject from a plane, will eject ONCE in their life.

‘An ejection seat is an emergency, last ditch, all-else has failed alternative to death. That’s about it. It’s not at all uncommon for ejected pilots to suffer massive spinal damage, broken limbs, road rash… the list of injuries that can occur as a result of ejection are numerous.

‘Having spinal damage sucks. But it beats dying.

‘b) Most pilots are healthy, 20–35 year old males.

‘Can you imagine the consequences of ejecting an 85 year old grandmother? What about a 4 year old boy? What about lap infants?

c) An ejection seat is a bomb.

‘When that handle gets pulled, the seat literally explodes out of the plane. In the space of microseconds, explosive bolts rip open the canopy above the pilots head, and then a rocket under his seat ignites, launching the pilot into the air. The pilot is braced for impact and in the proper launch position.

‘Now imagine filling a commercial jetliner with 300+ of these things. Heck – TSA gets upset if I bring scissors onto a plane…

d) They’re INCREDIBLY expensive and heavy.

‘Remember – this is a bomb. Fighter pilots can use it because they only need to eject 50 feet into the air… and fighter jets have nothing but thrust. A fighter jet is basically an engine with wings to steer it. Fighter jets can handle the weight. On a commercial jetliner where every pound of cargo requires extra fuel, this simply isn’t possible.’

Chatterton continues;

e) It’s not necessary.

‘For every accident like Ethiopian Airlines, we’d have 10 ‘inadvertent detonations.’ (And now that we’ve punched a giant hole into our fuselage at altitude, we’ve got a host of other problems.)

‘A passenger airline is incredibly safe. Can you imagine what would have happened to US Airways 1549 if Chesley Sullenberger ordered everyone to eject? This was the infamous ‘Miracle on the Hudson.’

‘Instead of pictures like this, with a bunch of alive passengers, we’d have stories of Grandma hanging in a chute off the Empire State building… Babies getting run over by taxi cabs… people smacking into the side of buildings and falling to their death… people landing in the Hudson and drowning because they’re on their own and unable to be assisted…

f) The public would REVOLT.

‘People already complain about lack of legroom, or flight attendants getting snarky about the seatbelt sign. Now imagine taking a 6 hour flight where you’re strapped into this?

Swiss Air Force flight suit and ejection seat.

‘No. Let’s keep everyone where they’re safest. Inside the plane.

g) A high speed, high-altitude ejection would rip your clothes off.

‘(And you’d need oxygen for the entire descent.) Let’s just leave the oxygen issue aside. Let’s assume that through modern magic, you can breathe from 40,000 feet. But look around you after you’ve ejected… remember that 280 pound sales guy with bad breath? He’s hanging under a chute… naked. The old lady who tried to poach your seat? Hanging out beside you, naked. The teenage boy with acne and confidence issues has his clothes in shreds hanging off him…’

Chatterton concludes;

‘Oh – by the way, even if you can breathe… it’s well below freezing.’

Photo credit: U.S. Air Force, Greg L and Sandstein via Wikipedia

Dario Leone

Dario Leone is an aviation, defense and military writer. He is the Founder and Editor of “The Aviation Geek Club” one of the world’s most read military aviation blogs. His writing has appeared in The National Interest and other news media. He has reported from Europe and flown Super Puma and Cougar helicopters with the Swiss Air Force.

Recent Posts

USAF T-39A Pilot who Classified First in his UPT Class Tells why He Chose to Fly the Sabreliner Business Jet instead of the F-15 Eagle Fighter Jet

The F-15 Eagle The F-15 Eagle is an all-weather, extremely maneuverable, tactical fighter designed to… Read More

14 hours ago

The K-19, the first Soviet nuclear-powered strategic missile submarine that experienced a reactor failure on the first missile-firing voyage

The K-19 Project 658 (NATO reporting name Hotel I-class) K-19, the first Soviet nuclear-powered strategic… Read More

2 days ago

USAF F-16 Pilot explains why a Viper is more comfortable than a commercial airplane for long-haul flights

Fighter pilots Utilizing extraordinary skill and precision, fighter pilots push their aircraft’s limits with complete… Read More

2 days ago

US Navy EA-18G Growler pilot explains why pulling 9Gs feels like an elephant is standing on your chest (and it very quickly begins damaging your body)

G-LOC G-induced Loss Of Consciousness (abbreviated as G-LOC) is a term generally used in aerospace physiology to… Read More

3 days ago

US Navy F-4 RIO recalls when his Phantom II was mistakenly shot down by a US Navy F-4 (flown by a USAF exchange pilot)

The F-4 Phantom II In response to Navy requirements for a high-altitude interceptor to defend… Read More

3 days ago