Weapons

Former Naval Aviator explains why a fighter pilot prefers a longer-range (effective) missile over a faster and better maneuvering aircraft and over an outstanding radar

‘Long ago in flight school, I remember an instructor told us that we were not flying aircraft or fighters. No he said, we were merely flying weapon platforms, and it was the weapon, not the pilot or aircraft that was most important,’ John Chesire, former US Navy F-4 Phantom and F-14 Tomcat pilot.

Fighter aircraft are fixed-wing military aircraft designed primarily for air-to-air combat. In military conflict, the role of fighter aircraft is to establish air superiority of the battlespace. Domination of the airspace above a battlefield permits bombers and attack aircraft to engage in tactical and strategic bombing of enemy targets.

The key performance features of a fighter include not only its firepower but also its high speed and maneuverability and its onboard radar relative to the target aircraft.

‘Long ago in flight school, I remember an instructor told us that we were not flying aircraft or fighters. No he said, we were merely flying weapon platforms, and it was the weapon, not the pilot or aircraft that was most important,’ says John Chesire, former US Navy F-4 Phantom and F-14 Tomcat pilot, on Quora.

So, as a fighter pilot, what advantages would you rather have, a longer range missile, a faster and better maneuvering plane, or an outstanding radar?

Chesire explains;

‘Of course I want all three, but one rises to the surface of most desired. ‘Faster and better maneuvering aircraft: Without an adequate weapon system – radar and missiles – a fighter even though it can outmaneuver anything, is not desirable. The MiGs of my day were extremely maneuverable, albeit maybe not fast, except for the MiG-21. Worse, they possessed poor radar and weapon systems, that really limited their capability which negated their superior turning ability.

This print is available in multiple sizes from AircraftProfilePrints.com – CLICK HERE TO GET YOURS. F-14A Tomcat VF-21 Freelancers, NF200 / 161616 / 1996

‘Outstanding radar: I was fortunate to have at the time superlative radar, the AWG-9. It was so advanced for its time it could track 24 targets and attack with missiles six targets, simultaneously. That was then. Today the need for a long range and superlative radar is overshadowed by the AWACS capabilities. Better than a fighter’s radar, they see a much larger picture, and through data link can feed target information to the fighter, just as its own radar might.

‘A longer-range missile: This would be my most desirable choice, as long it was an effective missile. (Consider for instance, fire-and-forget, launch and leave missiles.) I am reminded of ancient and later pike men with their long 16-foot weapons that could reach out and touch the dragoon or swordsman, well before they could bring their weapons to bear on you. Pike men did not have to be “maneuverable” or fast, nor did they need “long range eyesight.” They just needed their “longer range weapon” to put the hurt on someone before they could do it to you.’

Chesire concludes;

‘Consider this; no matter what your fighter’s wonderful capabilities are, a Russian K-100 missile fired at 400km from you will get a lot more attention from you and much sooner, than you can fire your perhaps otherwise superior AIM-120D AMRAAM fired at its max range of 180 km at the Russian, no matter how much superior your fighter may be.’

Sailors aboard the USS Constitution perform a boarding pike drill for spectators during Boston Navy Week on Jun. 30, 2010.

Photo credit: U.S. Navy

Dario Leone

Dario Leone is an aviation, defense and military writer. He is the Founder and Editor of “The Aviation Geek Club” one of the world’s most read military aviation blogs. His writing has appeared in The National Interest and other news media. He has reported from Europe and flown Super Puma and Cougar helicopters with the Swiss Air Force.

Recent Posts

The story of the Royal Air Force CF-105 Arrow All-Weather Fighters that Never Were

It was on the basis of the Arrow’s future potential, more than CF-105 then-current design,… Read More

23 hours ago

The Argentine Air Force may buy surplus CH-46 Sea Knight medium-lift helicopter stored at 309 AMARG

The Argentine Air Force may give new life to the Boeing CH-46 medium-lift helicopter, retired… Read More

23 hours ago

Vietnam could buy the F-16 Block 70/72, the newest and most advanced Viper production configuration

The Biden administration is in talks with Vietnam over an agreement for the largest arms… Read More

2 days ago

The SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (aka R2-D2) worked by tracking the stars and was so powerful that it could see the stars even in daylight

Mounted behind the SR-71 Blackbird RSO’s cockpit, this unit, (that was affectionately dubbed “R2-D2” after… Read More

3 days ago