F4U-4 Vs Bf 109G-4 Vs Fw 190A-6 Vs P-51B: the US Navy test where the Corsair came out on top in all contests in terms of sheer combat

By Dario Leone
Nov 24 2025

In this article:

The Corsair

F4U-4 Vs Bf 109G-4 Vs Fw 190A-6 Vs P-51B: the US Navy test where the Corsair came out on top in all contests in terms of sheer combat

One of the most recognizable airplanes in history owing to its unique inverted gull wing design, the F4U Corsair remained in continual production from 1942 until 1952, with more than 12,500 examples of the aircraft delivered.

One of the Navy and Marine Corps’ finest fighters, Corsairs accounted for 2,140 Japanese aircraft shot down in World War II, and the sound the aircraft made when it was flying close air support missions during island campaigns inspired the Japanese to call the plane “Whistling Death.”

Corsair US Navy Test

Would the F4U have beaten German WWII fighters too?

Pete Feigal, Former Pro Military Artist and Aviation Expert, explains on Quora;

The story of how a captured Luftwaffe Fw 190 led to the development of the Spitfire Mk IX, the best close-in fighter of WWII

‘She did, and easily.

‘The Navy actually evaluated the F4U-4 vs the Bf 109G-4, Fw 190A-6 and P-51B Mustang in simulated combat and the Corsair clearly came (mostly) out on top in all contests, in terms of sheer combat. (The Fw 190 did well, too.)

‘Sheer combat-speed, dive, roll, turn? Corsair, not even close. The Bf 109 was agile for sure, at medium altitudes, and the Fw 190 was very maneuverable at low altitudes, but the Corsair’s 10 degree-adjustable flaps and strengths in the roll and dive found it out fighting the Germans and the P-51 in the Navy tests.

‘Ground attack? Corsair, not even close. The Corsair excelled at ground attack in both wars, carrying 4000lbs of bombs/rockets.

‘Both German aircraft were better armed, esp. the Fw 190 with cannons and MGs equal to 11 Browning M2 .50’s.

The better and more versatile combat aircraft by far

The Iconic F4U Corsair was Plagued by Troubles as a carrier aircraft but became the Primary USMC Fighter during WW II

‘Toughness/survivability, which is the most important? Corsair with its size, strength and esp. its air-cooled P&W R-2800 radial, the Fw 190 was a close second, with its air-cooled BMW 801 and duralum skin, but the Bf 109’s vulnerable liquid-cooled DB 605 was not even close, and very fragile, with the P-51 coming in third in this contest.

‘Corsair with two 154 gallon Navy drop tanks: 1,300 miles, not even close, double the ranges of the German fighters with the P-51B coming in first with a range of 1350 miles.

‘The Corsair’s ceiling at near 42,000 feet was significantly more than the Fw and 3,000 feet more than the Bf 109’s.’

Feigal concludes;

‘The Corsair was the better and more versatile combat aircraft by far.

‘Final tally was #1. Corsair, #2. Fw 190, #3. P-51, #4. Bf 109.’

P-51 Red Tail
This print is available in multiple sizes from AircraftProfilePrints.com – CLICK HERE TO GET  YOURS. P-51C-10 Flown by Tuskagee Airmen Col. Charles E. McGee, 302nd FS, 332nd FG, Italy

Photo credit: Kogo Own Work via Wikipedia and Bzuk at English Wikipedia, U.S. Navy and U.S. Air Force

Dario Leone

Dario Leone

Dario Leone is an aviation, defense and military writer. He is the Founder and Editor of “The Aviation Geek Club” one of the world’s most read military aviation blogs. His writing has appeared in The National Interest and other news media. He has reported from Europe and flown Super Puma and Cougar helicopters with the Swiss Air Force.

Dario Leone: All articles

Back to top